Contact Lens vs. Visian ICL | What's the Difference?

Icl vs contacts sharpen LR1 V2

What is the difference between a contact lens and the Visian ICL? Is the Visian ICL better than contacts or are contacts better than the ICL? Both are something that go into your eyes and help to correct your vision, but what sets them apart?

What is the Visian ICL?

The Visian ICL is an Implantable Collamer® Lens that is made up of a combination of collagen and polymer, which is biocompatible and made of the same material found in your natural eye. It’s placed in between the iris and cornea of your eye to give you clear, crisp vision.

The lens can help with:

  • Nearsightedness (myopia) – Visian ICL
  • Astigmatism – Visian Toric ICL
  • Provides UV protection

The Visian ICL within the US is currently approved for:

  • Visian ICL – corrects severe myopia (up to -20 diopters)1
  • Visian Toric ICL – corrects myopia (up to -16 diopters) & astigmatism (up to 4 diopters)

By addressing your visual needs, the Visian ICL provides a lens uniquely made for your eyes.

Why do some people call Visian ICL an "implantable contact lens"?

Commonly called the implantable contact lens, Visian ICL is essentially implanting a thin collamer lens into your eye that does the job of what a contact lens does, with the possibilites of additional benefits. This provides the option of the lens being permanently placed in your eye, with the option of being removed should your vision need further correction. Thus giving the nickname of the implantable contact lens.

Although some people say the Visian ICL is like an implantable contact lens, the official name of the lens is an Implantable Collamer® Lens, or ICL for short.

What is a contact lens?

Contact lenses are a thin plastic lens2 that lay on top of your cornea in the eye to correct one’s vision.3 Depending on the type you choose, contacts can treat one or more of the following:

  • Nearsightedness (myopia)
  • Farsightedness (hyperopia)
  • Age-related farsightedness (presbyopia)
  • Astigmatism

They come in a variety of types3 such as:

  • Soft contact lens vs hard contact lens (gas permeable vs. rigid gas permeable)
  • Day Wear vs. Night Wear
  • Daily, by-weekly, monthly, yearly
  • Toric contact lens (for astigmatism)
  • Bifocal contact lens

All these options may make it difficult to choose the best for your eyes without a professional consultation, compared to the Visian ICL that can provide a simple pathway towards improving your vision with one simple procedure.

Contact lens (left) and the Visian ICL (right)

What is the size difference between contact lenses and the Visian ICL lens?

Contact lens are on average between 14mm to 16mm in diameter5 while the Visian ICL is on average between 12mm – 13mm in diameter.6

They are similar in sizing and both are able to provide clear vision for your visual needs.

Do you have to maintain the Visian ICL lens like a contact lens?

The answer is no! You don’t have to take them off every day like you do a contact lens. The Visian ICL is a lens that is permanent, yet removable, a benefit over most contact lenses.

The procedure usually takes 20-30 minutes and typically only a few checkups are required after getting the Visian ICL procedure. Any additional checkups would be based on your unique needs and doctor recommendations. Should a change in one’s vision occurs, a visit to an ophthalmologist is recommended.

Because contact lenses are not implanted into the eye, most require weekly, if not daily care. They are designed to be temporary and removable at will, so some tend to be more susceptible to drying out and/or getting dirty through normal day wear. Contact lens solution should be used to clean out one’s lenses with clean hands to help prevent any risk of eye infections from bacteria.

What are the risks of wearing contact lenses compared to the Visian ICL?

Contact lenses can pose various dangers ranging from eye infections and possibly inducing blindness. Some problems caused by contact lenses include wearing them longer than recommended or taking them out without washing your hands, transferring bacteria directly into your eyes.

In 2016, over 80% of people between 12 - 24 years of age engaged in behavior that put their eye heath at risk.


Additionally, the cleaning solution for contacts are not always 100% “accurate” as it doesn’t remove all buildups in the lens such as certain proteins. This can lead to problems caused by the lenses such as increased risks of eye infection or irritations.7

This may be caused by:8

  • Not washing hands before touching contact lens
  • Not rinsing out your contact case with clean solution
  • Wearing contact lens longer than recommended
  • Sleeping with your contact lens
  • “Topping off” solution in your case (aka not discard all leftover contact lens solution after each use)
  • Swimming with contact lenses
  • Exposing your contact lenses to any water

With the Visian ICL, you won’t have to worry about remembering to clean your contacts or swimming with them on! It eliminates that hassle and simply provides you will clear vision.

There are many pros and cons of contact lenses, but the main difference for Jennifer Puno was that the Visian ICL was permanent, yet removable. Check out Jennifer’s testimonial on how this procedure changed her life.

Important Safety Information

The Visian ICL is intended for the correction of moderate to high nearsightedness. Visian ICL and Visian TICL surgery is intended to safely and effectively correct nearsightedness between -3.0 D to -15.0 D, the reduction in nearsightedness up to -20.0 D and treatment of astigmatism from 1.0 D to 4.0 D. If you have nearsightedness within these ranges, Visian ICL surgery may improve your distance vision without eyeglasses or contact lenses. Because the Visian ICL corrects for distance vision, it does not eliminate the need for reading glasses, you may require them at some point, even if you have never worn them before.

Implantation of the Visian ICL is a surgical procedure, and as such, carries potentially serious risks. Please discuss the risks with your eye care professional. Complications, although rare, may include need for additional surgical procedures, inflammation, loss of cells from the back surface of the cornea, increase in eye pressure, and cataracts.

You should NOT have Visian ICL surgery if:

  • Your doctor determines that the shape of your eye is not an appropriate fit for the Visian ICL
  • You are pregnant or nursing
  • You do not meet the minimum endothelial cell density for your age at the time of implantation as determined by your eye doctor
  • Your vision is not stable as determined by your eye doctor

Before considering Visian ICL surgery you should have a complete eye examination and talk with your eye care professional about Visian ICL surgery, especially the potential benefits, risks, and complications. You should discuss the time needed for healing after surgery. For additional information with potential benefits, risks and complications please visit DiscoverICL.com

References

References

1Visian ICL Patient Information Booklet

2Sanders D. Vukich JA. Comparison of implantable collamer lens (ICL) and laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) for Low Myopia. Cornea. 2006 Dec; 25(10):1139-46.

3Naves, J.S. Carracedo, G. Cacho-Babillo, I. Diadenosine Nucleotid Measurements as Dry-Eye Score in Patients After LASIK and ICL Surgery. Presented at American Society of Cataract and Refractive Surgery (ASCRS) 2012.

4Shoja, MR. Besharati, MR. Dry eye after LASIK for myopia: Incidence and risk factors. European Journal of Ophthalmology. 2007; 17(1): pp. 1-6.

5Lee, Jae Bum et al. Comparison of tear secretion and tear film instability after photorefractive keratectomy and laser in situ keratomileusis. Journal of Cataract & Refractive Surgery , Volume 26 , Issue 9 , 1326 - 1331.

6Parkhurst, G. Psolka, M. Kezirian, G. Phakic intraocular lens implantantion in United States military warfighters: A retrospective analysis of early clinical outcomes of the Visian ICL. J Refract Surg. 2011;27(7):473-481.

Select Your Region

Select a Region